Genworth: Tougher regulation and higher capital requirements for lenders accelerated the fall in homeownership

  • Unprecedented collapse in the number of people able to buy their first home as tougher regulation and greater capital requirements since 2007 take their toll
  • Even with Help to Buy, first time buyer numbers in 2014 will fall 41% short of demand – pushing the total number of frustrated buyers beyond 2 million
  • Regulation has limited the availability of loans and pushed up pricing – but sustaining the house building rise depends on support for first time buyers with limited deposits
  • Permanent solution needed to help ordinary families access homeownership while protecting the safety of the financial system
  • The much higher cost of high LTV borrowing means the average first time buyer currently needs £21,000 extra income for a 95% LTV loan than a 75% LTV loan – shutting many out of the market.

LONDON, 8-9-2014 — /EuropaWire/ — The decline of high loan to value (LTV) mortgage lending in the UK has led to a 1.8m shortfall in the number of first time buyers since 2007, according to a new report from Genworth, the global mortgage insurer.

The report highlights how tougher regulation and higher capital requirements for lenders have accelerated the fall in homeownership and dramatically reduced the number of people – especially younger households – who are able to buy their first home.

Using government and industry data, Genworth’s analysis of first time buyer numbers compared with expected demand shows people entered owner-occupation at a consistent rate from 1985 to 2006, with 10.26m buying their first homes, only slightly under the expected 10.29m based on population trends.

But since 2007, an unprecedented collapse has taken place, creating a large and persistent deficit in first time buyer numbers. The combined effect over seven years from 2007 to 2013 is a shortfall of 1.8m first time buyers against expected demand (see chart 1). Put simply, 1.8m of the UK population who would have been expected to buy their first home since 2007 have not done so.

Even with the government’s Help to Buy schemes in place, figures for the first six months of 2014 indicate there will be 296,200 first time buyers this year when demographic trends suggest there should be 500,000 to satisfy demand. This annual deficit of 41% or 203,800 will push total frustrated demand from the previous 1.8m to beyond 2 million.

Chart 1: rise and fall of first time buyer numbers relative to demand – cumulative frustrated demand reached 1.8m by 2013

Genworth Tougher regulation and higher capital requirements for lenders accelerated the fall in homeownership

 

Long term plan needed to support first time buyers while protecting the financial system

As a result, the report warns that the UK is facing a large and rapidly growing crisis in access to homeownership alongside the crisis of inadequate house building.

It highlights the impact of the high LTV lending drought on the house building collapse during the recession – high LTV borrowers made up 40% of new build sales before the financial crisis – and examines the policy response to correct the fault through the dual Help to Buy schemes, which have accounted for virtually all the growth in new housing output over the last year.

Genworth argues these temporary government interventions need to be replaced with a permanent, market driven mechanism that supports access to homeownership for ordinary families while protecting the safety of the financial system.

Without a permanent long term replacement for Help to Buy to bolster high LTV lending, new building rates could quickly fall back or properties could get to market and not find buyers among the key frustrated demographic.

A system of mortgage insurance – which already exists in varied forms in Canada, Australia, the U.S., Hong Kong and the Netherlands – would provide the UK with the missing piece of its regulatory jigsaw: a comprehensive framework to mitigate the risk of high LTV lending by transferring it from a mortgage lender to an insurance provider designed to bear the risk.

Mortgage insurance for high LTV loans – backed by capital relief for lenders –would ensure prudently underwritten mortgages can be available in the quantity and at the price required to support first time buyer aspirations in the UK.

As a regulatory tool, it would also reconcile the twin objectives of keeping the financial system safe and keeping homeownership open as an option for the majority, without calling on taxpayer funds to prop up the first time buyer market.

Simon Crone, vice president for mortgage insurance (Europe) at Genworth, comments:

“The scale of frustrated demand is growing larger by the day. Interventions so far have barely begun to make any inroads into a problem that threatens to permanently undermine UK homeownership, with younger households bearing the brunt of the impact.

The UK is facing a dual crisis of first time buyer lending alongside low house building. There is plenty of scope to improve on Help to Buy, which remains a temporary fix to a problem currently hardwired into the market. But we must avoid its removal until there is a long term solution in place. Delaying these vital decisions will only exacerbate the issue.

Help to Buy must become a precursor to a permanent system where mortgage insurance for high LTV loans – backed by capital relief – plays an ongoing role in helping first time buyers access the market, ensuring a sustainable rise in house building and protecting the safety of lenders and the financial system.”

Regulation has pushed the price of high LTV loans out of reach for many buyers

Genworth’s report shows that high LTV lending was crucial to advancing and sustaining UK homeownership from the 1930s onwards, and its subsequent decline has been the key factor in falling rates of owner-occupation with 25-34 year olds hit hardest.

Tougher regulation since 2008/9 has reinforced a shift of focus away from first time buyers in the mortgage market, contributing to a dramatic reduction in high LTV mortgages and pushing up their cost for lenders and borrowers.

Comparing the average cost of a two-year fixed mortgage at 75% and 95% LTV in July 2014, borrowers effectively paid a rate of 15.8% on the balance between 75% and 95% compared to 2.5% up to 75% LTV.

It means on an average first time buyer home of £147,000, a 75% LTV borrower would pay £496 a month while a 95% LTV borrower would pay £843. Assuming both were assessed as being able to pay up to 30% of their net income on their mortgage, the 75% LTV borrower would need a gross salary of £24,800 while the 95% LTV borrower would need £45,800, hugely restricting the number who can take out a high LTV mortgage.

Simon Crone, vice president for mortgage insurance (Europe) at Genworth, continues:

“The insurance sector has the capacity and willingness to replace much of the government’s exposure under Help to Buy and support a transition to a permanent scheme that helps rescue owner-occupation from its current decline.

We urge government and regulators to work with private insurers to address the two most pressing priorities in the housing market: boosting construction of new homes and supporting first time buyer access at a price they can afford.

Both objectives depend on the availability of high LTV mortgages, and a solution that delivers these outcomes while protecting financial stability is the missing piece of the UK’s regulatory jigsaw.”

Media contacts

For more information, please contact:

Andy Lane,The Wriglesworth Consultancy, a.lane@wriglesworth.com, 0207 427 1400

Suzy Awford, Public Relations for Genworth Financial, suzy.awford@genworth.com, 0208 380 2080/07971 142 233

Rob Griffiths, Public Relations for Genworth Financial, rob@whitedragoncomms.co.uk, 07983 641 566

About the Genworth report
Genworth’s report – ‘After Help to Buy: reconciling a healthy mortgage market and safe lending’ – was authored by Rob Thomas, Director of Research at Wriglesworth Research and formerly a Bank of England economist, a high profile analyst at the investment bank UBS and senior policy adviser to the Council of Mortgage Lenders. Rob was also the project originator and manager at the European Mortgage Finance Agency project and created the blueprint for the government’s NewBuy mortgage scheme.

About Genworth Mortgage Insurance in the UK
Genworth focuses on mortgage insurance and lifestyle protection in the UK and Europe, working with building societies, banks and other financial institutions. Since 1993, Genworth has been offering flexible mortgage insurance solutions to suit different lender requirements, whether that is on a loan-by-loan basis or at a portfolio level.

Our protection to lenders makes high loan-to-value mortgage loans (where the borrower does not have a large deposit) available to good credit-quality borrowers. Genworth is regulated by the PRA and FCA, and has unmatched expertise and capacity including a unique arrangement with highly rated reinsurers.

About Genworth Financial
Genworth Financial, Inc. (NYSE: GNW) is a leading Fortune 500 insurance holding company committed to helping families become more financially secure, self-reliant and prepared for the future. Genworth has leadership positions in long term care insurance and mortgage insurance and competitive offerings in life insurance and fixed annuities that assist consumers in solving their insurance, retirement and home ownership needs.

Genworth operates through three divisions: U.S. Life Insurance, which includes life insurance, long term care insurance and fixed annuities; Global Mortgage Insurance, containing U.S. Mortgage Insurance and International Mortgage Insurance segments; and the Corporate and Other division, which includes the International Protection and Runoff segments. Products and services are offered through financial intermediaries, advisors, independent distributors and sales specialists. Genworth, headquartered in Richmond, Virginia, traces its roots back to 1871 and became a public company in 2004. For more information, visit genworth.com. From time to time, Genworth releases important information via postings on its corporate website. Accordingly, investors and other interested parties are encouraged to enroll to receive automatic email alerts and Really Simple Syndication (RSS) feeds regarding new postings. Enrollment information is found under the “Investors” section of genworth.com. From time to time, Genworth’s publicly traded subsidiaries, Genworth MI Canada Inc. (TSX:MIC) and Genworth Mortgage Insurance Australia Limited (ASX:GMA), separately release financial and other information about their operations. This information can be found at http://www.genworth.com.au and http://genworth.ca.

Read the full After Help to Buy report here.

Comments are closed.